RECO
    Back to blog
    Brain-Drain Calculator

    Brain Drain in SMEs: What Every Resignation Truly Costs Your Company

    Andrew WestfallAndrew WestfallSales Partnership, RECOPublished Last edited 5 min read

    Most management reports show turnover as a percentage, in the same line year after year. What that rate costs is rarely written next to it. My view: as long as turnover appears only as a rate in the HR report and not as a euro amount in the annual plan, service SMEs with 50–500 employees will underestimate it.

    The obvious objection is that departures are part of doing business. For roles that are well documented and quick to refill, that is true. In consulting, engineering or tax advisory there are few such roles, because the value sits in client relationships and experience. The costly departure connects this cost assessment to preparing a useful handover. Knowledge preservation retains client history and decision context before a departure forces the remaining team to reconstruct them.

    Why the published figures are so far apart

    Anyone searching for the cost of a resignation finds numbers that seem to contradict each other.

    • Deloitte Austria (2019, survey of 110 managers): about EUR 14,900 per position.
    • Kompetenz Center Mitarbeiterbindung (Gunther Wolf, 2016, 112 companies with 1,000+ employees): at least EUR 43,069 per departure, of which EUR 16,819 are opportunity costs.
    • Gallup (2019): half to twice an annual salary, depending on the role.

    The figures count different things. If you include job ads, recruiters and onboarding, you end up near the Deloitte figure. Add lost output and the risk of a bad hire, as Wolf does, and you get almost three times as much (43,069 divided by 14,900 is about 2.9). Gallup works in salary multiples, so at the top of its range any position paying EUR 50,000 or more reaches six figures. For a service SME, I consider salary multiples the more honest basis.

    An annual calculation with your own numbers

    The calculation needs three inputs, and you already have all of them. The number of departures last year comes from HR records. Count voluntary departures and dismissals, not retirements with a planned handover. The gross annual salary of each affected position comes from payroll. The third input is a judgment no study can make for you. Gallup only gives the range of half to two annual salaries, not which role sits where.

    • Departures from well-documented roles that are quick to refill: annual salary times 0.5, Gallup's lower bound.
    • Departures from roles with their own client responsibility or a lot of experience: annual salary times a factor between 0.5 and 2, closer to 2 the harder the knowledge is to replace.
    • The sum of all lines is your annual cost of turnover.

    A public benchmark shows how wide that range is. Germany's Federal Statistical Office (Destatis) puts the median gross annual earnings of full-time employees in 2024 at EUR 52,159, including special payments. At half a salary that is about EUR 26,080 per departure, at twice a salary EUR 104,318. The same pay grade can cost four times as much depending on who leaves. That is why it pays to rate each position individually instead of using an average.

    Whatever the result, no line in the P&L is called "brain drain". The money hides in overtime, delayed projects and discounts for unhappy clients.

    What the Brain-Drain Calculator computes

    We built the Brain-Drain Calculator for your own numbers. You enter industry, headcount, average salary and turnover rate and get a first figure straight away that management, HR and finance can review together. It covers:

    • direct recruiting costs such as headhunters, job ads and internal interview time
    • vacancy costs from lost revenue and stalled projects
    • ramp-up costs, meaning lower productivity in the first months plus the time experienced colleagues spend
    • knowledge loss from undocumented client history and project experience
    • follow-on departures among close colleagues after a prominent exit
    • reputation costs from slower response times and more escalations

    How these items break down for a single person is shown in the worked example in What does it really cost when a key employee resigns?

    Where the lever is

    According to Gallup, 52 percent of employees who leave voluntarily say their manager or organisation could have done something to stop them leaving. In my view, much of that is decided in conversations that never happen, feedback that fizzles out and conflicts that come up too late.

    RECO is built for those conversations, with AI-supported preparation, help during the conversation and documentation that stays when a manager leaves. That pays off twice. Key people are more likely to stay, and the knowledge of those who leave anyway stays in the company. Which roles to tackle first is shown by the knowledge map in our guide to brain drain in companies.

    For any investment in retention there is a simple break-even calculation. Multiply the number of departures a measure prevents or hands over cleanly each year by the cost per departure from your calculation above. If the result is higher than the measure's annual cost, it pays for itself. For roles at the top of Gallup's range, a single departure can be enough. Check it with your own numbers in the calculator.

    Sources

    Related articles

    In a 30 minute software demo we show you how RECO secures and transfers knowledge in your company. Request a demo now and we'll get back to you with a proposed time.