What does it really cost when a key employee resigns?
When a key person resigns, a number often comes up very quickly: half to one annual salary. That rule of thumb sits at the low end of what Gallup and SHRM give for replacement, which is 50 to 200 percent of an annual salary. It is not wrong. For key roles I still think it is too low, because it leaves out an item that appears in no cost centre: the hours your remaining team spends searching, asking around and re-deciding in the months that follow.
You could argue that those hours are paid anyway and therefore cost nothing. That only holds if your people would otherwise not have done any billable work in that time. In a busy team, every hour spent searching is an hour a customer does not get. The costly departure connects these costs to offboarding and knowledge transfer. For SMEs, the case for knowledge preservation should include displaced billable work as well as recruitment costs, because reconstructing a departed expert's reasoning consumes existing capacity.
What the usual calculation leaves out
The visible costs are easy to list: job ads, recruiters, internal interview time, ramp-up with reduced productivity and possibly interim external support. All of that can be quantified. Four other items tend to stay out.
Rework
As soon as someone leaves who knew a process, the questions start. Colleagues look for documents, reconstruct decisions and call customers to clarify things that were settled long ago.
Lost customer history
In many SMEs a single person knows the backstory of a major account, with every commitment, exception and informal arrangement. When that person leaves, the relationship does not sour overnight. But response times grow, mistakes pile up, and the commercial effect often shows up only later, when a follow-up order fails to arrive.
Slower decisions
Teams that lack the reasoning behind past decisions decide more cautiously. They gather extra opinions, postpone and re-examine. Projects start later, quotes go out later, and that costs margin.
The quiet drain before the resignation
Disengagement often builds over a longer period. In the Gallup Engagement Index Germany 2025, 13 percent of employees have no emotional bond with their employer, and 39 percent of them are actively looking for a new job. In that phase, less gets documented and handed over. The loss starts long before the last working day.
The calculation for your own role
An example with made-up numbers won't help you much. The template below will, because every input comes from your own company. Only replacement has a published benchmark.
- Replacement: the role's gross annual salary times a factor between 0.5 and 2, the range given by Gallup and SHRM. For a key role I would not use the low end.
- People affected: the number of people who regularly rely on this person's knowledge. Ask the team lead, not the org chart.
- Extra time: the hours per week each of those people spends searching and asking around after the departure. Estimate the first weeks and the period after that separately, because the successor can answer more with every week.
- Hourly rate: the fully loaded cost per hour from your cost accounting, or the billing rate in billable teams.
- Decisions to rework: the hours it takes to make a decision again without the original reasoning.
- Delayed orders: the contribution margin your sales team books as lost when a project starts late.
The hidden costs are then people affected times extra hours per week times weeks times hourly rate, plus hours for reworked decisions times hourly rate, plus lost contribution margin. Add replacement and you have the total cost of the departure.
Two things stand out as soon as you run the numbers. The number of people affected enters linearly: if twice as many people depend on a role's knowledge, search time doubles. And the time horizon matters. If you only count up to the successor's first day, you leave out exactly the months in which the questions come up. Count up to the point where the successor can explain the role's significant decisions on their own.
For a first order of magnitude without a spreadsheet, use our knowledge loss calculator. If you want to know what turnover costs across the whole company over a year, read What every resignation truly costs your company. Which roles are worth calculating in the first place is shown by the knowledge map in Brain drain in companies.
What follows from this
If the most expensive part is the missing reasoning rather than the replacement, the lever is ongoing documentation. The question is where it happens. I recommend moving it into the meetings your team already holds every week, instead of catching up at the end of a project. That is what AI-supported conversation documentation is for. The successor will need the same knowledge later, as our onboarding use case shows.
The first step costs nothing. Write down the five roles whose departure tomorrow would do real damage. For each one, check whether anyone besides that person could explain the last ten significant decisions. Wherever the answer is no, you have found your risk. More in the topic hub Knowledge management.
Sources
- Gallup, This Fixable Problem Costs U.S. Businesses $1 Trillion (2019)
- Gallup, Engagement Index Germany 2025
- SHRM Executive Network, The Myth of Replaceability (replacement: 50 to 200 percent of annual salary)
- Deloitte Austria, Turnover and its impact on companies (2019)
- Kompetenz Center Mitarbeiterbindung (Gunther Wolf), turnover cost study 2016
Frequently asked questions
How high are the costs of a resignation in a mid-sized company?+
It depends on what you count. Deloitte Austria arrived at about EUR 14,900 per position in 2019, Gunther Wolf's turnover cost study at no less than EUR 43,069 per departure in 2016, and Gallup at half to twice an annual salary. For key roles, salary multiples are more realistic than a flat amount.
Which cost items are usually overlooked?+
Rework, lost customer history, slower decisions and the quiet knowledge drain before the resignation. You can catch part of it in the exit interview by asking specifically which three customers, processes or exceptions nobody else knows about.
How can knowledge loss be avoided?+
By recording the reasoning continuously rather than only at handover. A workable rule is to note three things for every significant decision: why, which alternatives were rejected and which exceptions apply. Once a quarter, check whether that is actually happening for your five most critical roles.
Related articles
In a 30 minute software demo we show you how RECO secures and transfers knowledge in your company. Request a demo now and we'll get back to you with a proposed time.
